Mid-market brands need a right-fit agency they can (really) trust.

If you’re a marketing leader for a mid-market brand, you probably have a hard time getting everything you need from your agency partner. 

There are reasons for that. You face the same marketing challenges of larger global brands and have all the same marketing needs. But you’re working with smaller marketing budgets (typically $1 to $10 million per year) and have a much smaller team that is responsible for, well, everything.

To add to the pressure-cooker scenario, boards and finance leaders are asking marketing to carry more of the growth mandate — with limited additional headcount. Mid-market CMOs need reliable value measurements that can survive a CFO’s scrutiny.

Which is why one of the most important decisions you can make as a mid-market CMO  is who to tap as your agency partner. The agency landscape is vast. There are imperfect fits:

• If you rely on a collection of small specialty agencies, you’ll be left stitching outputs together from multiple partners, which is labor intensive and rarely works.
• If you hire a holding company, you’ll find their pricing models are optimized for much larger budgets, and talent is pulled to flagship accounts. 

The right agency partner will understand the challenges facing your lean internal team, a finite budget, and a need for end-to-end accountability. Here’s how to get what you’re looking for. 

What to look for in an agency partner

1. An agency with outcome-backed service design

As a mid-market brand CMO, you no longer need a channel plan; you’ve evolved beyond vanity metrics like reach and engagement. You need an agency that grounds its strategies and recommendations in your business, the strategic priorities of the C-suite and your economic model. Early conversations with your agency should align around revenue goals, margins, sales capacity, deal cycles and customer lifetime value. 

Any scope you sign with your partner should specify how the work (brand work, campaigns, content, media) will hit the right numbers. Success metrics should include things that also matter to the CFO: pipeline value, win-rates in target segments, payback period on marketing investment, and improvement in unit economics. 

2. Integrated teams structured around the buyer journey

Mid-market brands need a team that is complete and completely integrated. Your ideal agency will organize squads that combine the players needed in strategy, creative, media and analytics. While each person should have a clearly defined role to play, they all should have a view of the whole. That’s critical. This structure allows the same team to see how a positioning decision affects creative, how creative affects click-through and conversion, and how both show up in pipeline data. 

For the client, the result is fewer handoffs and a single group of people who understand both the creative narrative and the math of the business. And how these two things fit together.

3. Right-sized martech and data disciplines

Mid-market CMOs often sit on underused technology stacks that were implemented with enterprise ambitions but maintained with limited staff. As a result, CRMs, marketing automation, and analytics platforms often represent untapped potential. The right agency for mid-market brands will effortlessly help you do more with what you have by providing pragmatic marketing-ops and analytics support. They will:

• Simplify data flows so there is one primary source of truth for leads, opportunities, and revenue.
• Implement basic but reliable tracking of campaigns across channels.
• Design dashboards that answer the C-suite’s questions instead of mirroring tool interfaces. 

The goal here isn’t to create an enterprise data-science team, but to make sure the fundamentals support strong decision making and business needs.

4. Flexible engagement and pricing models

In response to continuous market uncertainty, mid-market brands need agencies that can flex and evolve. At the same time, they need agencies with a strong understanding of the business and whose teams can build trusted, consultative relationships with key decision makers. The ideal service model between agencies and these brands often looks like:

• A core retainer for ongoing strategy, orchestration, and critical execution capability
• Clearly defined projects or sprints for launches, repositioning, or experimentation
• Performance or value-based components in cases where both sides can agree on how value will be measured. 

This flexibility allows brands to scale up or down around product cycles and market conditions while keeping a consistent partner in place.

What an exceptional brand-marketing relationship looks like in practice

The agency partner you need is not the ones with the largest networks or the most awards, but the ones that can reliably do three things: 

• Help you choose where you can win and say no to distractions.
• Build and run an integrated growth engine that fits your size and sales motion.
• Provide measurement and insights strong enough to guide real business decisions.

In other words, the agency you need will treat your mid-market brand and the partnership as a distinct design problem with its own economics, constraints, and opportunities. That’s what modern, accountable marketing partnerships should be. Mid-market brands deserve nothing less.

Get more performance marketing content from FINN.